AI-generated image of a salamander on damp leaf litter in a forest

Why Do Salamanders Make Noise? The Rare Sounds Explained

Most salamanders are silent, and none sing like frogs, but a few make sounds. The best-known is the California giant salamander, which can bark, chirp or growl when threatened. Other species make clicks, whistles or squeaks by moving air through the mouth or gill slits. Researchers think most of these sounds are defensive or simply a side effect of moving air, not a way to chat with other salamanders.

Walk through a damp forest at night and you will hear frogs, not salamanders. Yet a handful of salamanders can make noise, and the sounds are surprising. One species even barks.

Sources do not fully agree on how much salamanders vocalize, so this guide sets out what each one says. It then explains how the sounds are made and why they likely exist.

How this was made: prepared with AI assistance and checked against the sources listed at the end. Images are AI-generated illustrations, not photographs of real animals or products.

Key Takeaways

  • Most salamanders are voiceless and do not give mating calls like frogs.
  • Some species still make clicks, whistles, squeaks, chirps or barks.
  • The California giant salamander has confirmed vocal cords and can bark.
  • Most sounds appear to be defensive or a by-product of moving air.
  • A large salamander that is making noise is scared, so leave it alone.
Infographic with five points about why salamanders make noise, from rare sounds to four sound mechanisms and defence
Save or share this infographic.

Do salamanders make sounds at all?

It depends on which source you read. Ohio State University Extension states that salamanders do not make mating calls or any other vocalizations, in contrast to frogs that call each spring. That is a fair summary of most salamanders, which stay quiet.

However, a review by zoologist T. Paul Maslin in University of Colorado Studies collected older reports of sound in many salamanders and added his own observations. It lists sound in species from several families, so the better answer is rare, quiet and mostly defensive.

AI-generated image of a forest floor with ferns and a dirt path
Salamanders are mostly quiet forest animals. AI-generated illustration.

How salamanders produce sound

Maslin described four different ways that salamanders make noise. Only one of them is a true voice.

  1. Mouth clicks: air rushes into the mouth through suddenly parted, moist lips, as reported in newts and the tiger salamander.
  2. Whistles: air is forced out through the gill slits, as reported in the aquatic Amphiuma means.
  3. Squeaks: the floor of the mouth pushes air through a valve, as reported in plethodontids such as Aneides.
  4. True voice: air from the lungs passes over laryngeal valves. Maslin confirmed vocal cords in the California giant salamander.

The California giant salamander: the barking exception

The California giant salamander (Dicamptodon ensatus) is the standout. CalHerps reports that when threatened it often makes a low, rattling, bark-like sound. Recordings also include clicks, chirps and growls, and a juvenile uncovered from leaf litter gave a click, then a chirp, then a drawn-out growl.

Size matters. The same source notes that large adults can deliver a painful bite. A small adult in an Acoustic Atlas recording, held briefly by researchers, made only a very quiet chirp. Save the Redwoods describes this animal as one of only two salamanders that vocalize, but Maslin’s older list shows more species make some noise.

AI-generated image of a mossy log beside a small forest stream
Damp logs and streams are typical salamander habitat. AI-generated illustration.

Why salamanders make noise

Maslin concluded that sound in most salamanders serves a defensive role. Some noises look accidental, such as air forced out during a sudden squeeze. Others may startle or confuse a predator. CalHerps cites Stebbins and Cohen, who say the sounds of the related coastal giant salamander are thought to startle predators.

Maslin also noted a few reports of sounds during breeding. He suggested a sexual function was possible but not confirmed. Without more recent studies, treat that idea as an open question.

SoundExample speciesHow it is madeLikely purpose
Click or kissNewts, tiger salamanderAir drawn into the mouthDefence or by-product
WhistleAmphiuma meansAir forced from gill slitsNot confirmed
SqueakAneides lugubrisMouth floor pushes air through a valveDefence
Bark, chirp, growlCalifornia giant salamanderAir from the lungs over vocal cordsDefence when threatened

What to do if you hear a salamander

A noisy salamander is a stressed salamander. Watch from a distance, avoid handling it and do not poke it. Large giant salamanders can bite. If you move leaf litter or logs, put them back the way you found them.

Sound production is also linked to breathing. Our guide on whether salamanders have lungs explains why some species can push air from the lungs while many cannot. For defence by toxins, see are salamanders venomous.

Health note The CDC says even healthy reptiles and amphibians can carry Salmonella. Wash your hands with soap and running water after any contact with an amphibian or its environment.
Disclaimer General information, not veterinary advice. Wild salamanders should not be collected, and laws vary, so check your state wildlife agency.

What older records report, species by species

Maslin’s review, “The Production of Sound in Caudate Amphibia,” gathers reports going back to the 1700s. The excerpt carries no publication year and cites field observations through 1947, so it is old. Most entries are anecdotes by single observers, not controlled studies. Read them as clues, not measurements.

SalamanderReported soundObserver or detail
Amphiuma meansShrill whistle after a fallHay (1888); Baker (1937) tied it to air leaving the gill slits
Aneides lugubrisMouse-like squeakRitter and Miller (1899); Maslin, 15 to 20 occasions
Eurycea bislineataSoft squeaks about one second apartGeyer (1927), for up to an hour
Triturus torosusLow kissing soundsMaslin, March 1941, when taken from a stream
Dicamptodon ensatusLoud, low, resonant barkMyers (1930); Maslin, 1940

The arboreal salamander squeak

Maslin recorded squeaks from the arboreal salamander (Aneides lugubris) between 1936 and 1945, on about fifteen to twenty occasions. The sound came when animals were swept or prodded, usually five or six squeaks before stopping.

One subadult adopted a gaping threat posture before squeaking when touched. Most squeaking animals were about three-quarters grown. Maslin noted that these animals did not try to escape afterward, which fits a defensive startle.

More on the California giant salamander

CalHerps gives adult lengths of 6.7 to 12 inches, and says the species lives in wet coastal forests in California, usually within 50 meters of cold streams or seepages. It is mostly nocturnal, and adults forage on rainy nights, especially during the first heavy autumn rains.

Maslin’s 1940 specimen barked when lifted or teased, usually with a sideways body jerk. The bark was loud, low-pitched and resonant, and it could still be provoked after several weeks in captivity. His dissection found a larynx with rudimentary vocal folds, more complex in Dicamptodon than in the tiger salamander he also dissected.

CalHerps lists the species as California Species of Special Concern and the IUCN as Near Threatened, with habitat loss from forest removal and road building a concern. A salamander that barks is also one that needs wet forest.

Is the sound a warning, an accident or a signal?

Authors have disagreed for a long time. Nobel (1931) dismissed these noises as accidental, with no known effect on other animals. Maslin disagreed in part. He suggested that sounds linked to normal breathing may be accidental, but that an unexpected sound could disrupt a predator’s response sequence.

He tied the Dicamptodon bark to escape attempts, which he saw as a more advanced pattern. He also noted that Geyer’s observations of Eurycea, the spotted salamander and Salamandra might suggest a sexual function, though that was not confirmed. Maslin’s sixth conclusion was that in most species, sound production is part of a defense mechanism.

Why salamander sound is so hard to study

The sounds are brief and usually tied to disturbance. In a box of about twenty tiger salamanders, Maslin heard clicking only during the first excitement, such as feeding or wetting the soil. The newts he took from a stream made their kissing sounds four or five times and did not repeat them when recaptured.

Some are barely audible. Spallanzani reported a very low whistle from newts that was heard only when they surfaced to exchange air, and faint at four paces. A sound that quiet, made rarely, is easy to miss, which is one reason reports are scattered.

Old records can also contradict one another. For the siren (Siren lacertina), a 1765 specimen account and a 1769 dissertation described a croaking or song-like sound, while Barton in 1821 denied any song but reported a hissing noise. Disagreements like this are why the claims here are tied to named observers.

Life history of the barking giant

CalHerps reports that females lay 135 to 200 eggs in a hidden nest chamber and guard them until they hatch. Larvae develop in water and usually transform after 18 to 24 months, though some take three years. Gilled adults that stay aquatic occur in many populations and may outnumber transformed adults.

If you hear one: a short field guide

  1. Stop and keep your distance. Sounds in the records came when animals were handled, swept or teased, so a noisy salamander is a disturbed one.
  2. Do not repeat the disturbance to get a second sound.
  3. If you can, record the audio and note the date, place, weather and the animal’s size.
  4. Leave logs, rocks and leaf litter as you found them.
  5. Check your state wildlife agency before collecting or moving any wild amphibian.
  6. Wash your hands with soap and running water afterward. The CDC says children younger than 5 years old should not handle or touch reptiles or amphibians or their environments.

Common mistakes about salamander sounds

  • Saying salamanders are completely silent. Ohio State Extension says they make no vocalizations, yet older records report squeaks, clicks and barks.
  • Saying only one species makes noise. Save the Redwoods says two salamanders vocalize, while Maslin lists more.
  • Treating every sound as a voice. Only some come from the larynx; others are air moving through the mouth or gill slits.
  • Provoking an animal to hear it. This stresses wildlife and can lead to a bite from a large adult.
  • Treating century-old anecdotes as current science. Check for recent studies before repeating a claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can salamanders scream?

Some species make short squeaks, chirps or barks when threatened, according to CalHerps and Maslin. Most never make a sound.

Do salamanders have vocal cords?

Maslin confirmed vocal cords in the California giant salamander. Many other sounds come from air moving through the mouth or gill slits, not a true voice.

Do salamanders make mating calls?

Ohio State Extension says they do not. Maslin noted a few possible breeding-related sounds but said a sexual function was not confirmed.

Which salamander is the loudest?

The California giant salamander is the best-documented example, with a rattling, bark-like call when threatened.

Is it safe to pick up a noisy salamander?

No. It is stressed, and large species can bite. Wash your hands after any contact, and avoid handling wild amphibians.

Bottom Line

Salamanders are mostly silent animals, but the exceptions are fascinating. A click, a squeak or a bark usually means danger, not a conversation.

If you want more background on these amphibians, read about what salamanders are known for and how their moist skin and unusual life cycle set them apart.

Sources

Similar Posts

2 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *