AI-generated image of an axolotl in an aquarium with feathery external gills

Which Amphibians Have Gills? Larvae, Axolotls and More

Almost all amphibians have gills as larvae. Tadpoles have internal gills, and salamander larvae have feathery external gills. Most species lose their gills at metamorphosis and switch to lungs, skin, or both. A few salamanders keep external gills for life, including the axolotl and mudpuppies. Adult frogs, toads, and most newts and salamanders have no gills.

Gills are the first breathing organs of most amphibians. They work only in water, so an animal that moves onto land has to change how it breathes.

This guide shows who has gills, who loses them, and who keeps them. It also explains how gill-less adults still get enough oxygen.

How this was made: prepared with AI assistance and checked against the sources listed at the end. Images are AI-generated illustrations, not photographs of real animals or products.

Key Takeaways

  • Frog and toad tadpoles have internal gills under a protective flap called the operculum.
  • Salamander and caecilian larvae have external gills.
  • Gills and their blood supply are lost or resorbed at metamorphosis in most species.
  • Axolotls and mudpuppies keep external gills as adults.
  • Gills work only in water, lungs only in air, and skin can work in both.
Infographic with five cards: tadpoles, salamander larvae, metamorphosis, gills for life, and lungless salamanders.
Save or share this infographic.

Gills in amphibian larvae

Britannica notes that frog and toad tadpoles have internal gills. A bony flap called the operculum covers them. Water enters the mouth, flows over the gills, and leaves through an opening on the side of the body.

Salamander larvae have external gills instead. These are visible outside the body and set larvae apart from adults. Caecilian larvae also have external gills.

AI-generated image of a single tadpole swimming in a shallow pond
Tadpoles breathe with internal gills. AI-generated illustration.

What happens to gills at metamorphosis

In frogs and toads, the gills and their blood supply disappear as lungs develop. In salamanders, the external gills are resorbed and the gill slits close as lungs develop, according to Britannica.

Rose and James (2013) add a useful detail. Tadpoles raised in low-oxygen water can grow more and larger gill filaments. Gill size responds to the environment.

Amphibians that keep their gills for life

Some salamanders skip the change and stay aquatic. Biologists call this neoteny: the adult keeps juvenile traits.

The axolotl is the best-known case. Crowner and colleagues (2019) describe non-metamorphosing axolotls as keeping larval traits, including external gills. In the lab, axolotls can be pushed to metamorphose with thyroid hormone treatment. They rarely do so on their own.

All mudpuppies (genus Necturus) are neotenic too, says the Missouri Department of Conservation. Their red, plume-like gills stay for life. Mudpuppies in warm, stagnant water grow larger gills than those in cool, fast, oxygen-rich water.

If you keep an axolotl, see our guide to keeping an axolotl tank cool.

AI-generated image of a mudpuppy salamander underwater among river rocks
Mudpuppies keep red external gills as adults. AI-generated illustration.

Why axolotls stay in the water

Crowner and colleagues (2019) report that axolotl thyroid hormone levels stay low during larval development. They do not rise the way they do in tiger salamanders, which always metamorphose.

Even so, an axolotl can complete metamorphosis when it is given thyroid hormone in the lab. The authors point to a likely problem further up the hormone chain, possibly in the hypothalamus or pituitary. They also warn that the evidence has limits, such as poor control of age, size, and sex in some studies.

Why gills only work in water

Rose and James (2013) explain the basic rule. Gills work only in water and lungs work only in air. Skin can work in both.

That is why lungs matter most when water holds little oxygen. In the same study, Xenopus tadpoles raised in well-oxygenated water with no access to air could still complete metamorphosis with stunted or absent lungs. Their skin likely supplied enough oxygen.

The takeaway is simple. An amphibian breathes with whatever its habitat allows, and many use more than one surface at once.

Gill status by amphibian group

GroupGills as larvaeGills as adults
Frogs and toadsInternal, under the operculumNo
Salamanders and newts that metamorphoseExternalNo, resorbed and slits close
AxolotlExternalYes, kept for life
MudpuppiesExternalYes, kept for life
CaeciliansExternalGill slit closes at metamorphosis

How adults breathe without gills

Most amphibians can exchange gas through the skin in water and in air. Rose and James (2013) note that some species lack lungs and rely on thin skin with dense blood vessels and folds that add surface area.

Lungless salamanders show this clearly. The National Park Service says they take in oxygen through the skin and through the lining of the mouth and throat.

The eastern hellbender, a large aquatic salamander, is described by the US Fish and Wildlife Service as breathing through its skin. Folds along its body add surface area. That is why it needs cool, clear, well-oxygenated streams.

Gills, lungs, and skin compared

  • Gills: work only in water. Found in larvae and in a few permanent aquatic salamanders.
  • Lungs: work only in air. They develop as larvae change into adults.
  • Skin: works in water and air, but it must stay moist.
Where the evidence is thin Sources list different examples of gilled adults, and not every species has been studied closely. This article names only the groups that our sources describe directly. Hellbenders and mudpuppies share some larval traits, but we only state the breathing details our sources give.
About this article General information, not veterinary advice. If a pet amphibian shows signs of illness, contact an exotics vet through the ARAV directory: https://arav.org/professionals/

Keeping a gilled pet: the axolotl

The Royal Veterinary College (RVC) axolotl care sheet says axolotls keep their gills because neoteny prevents normal metamorphosis. They breathe mainly through the gills, with some gas exchange through the skin, and they have rudimentary lungs.

The sheet does not describe what healthy or unhealthy gills look like, and the other sources we opened do not either. If gills look unusual, ask an exotics vet rather than relying on an online description.

What the sheet does cover is the water the gills sit in:

  • Temperature: 16 to 18 C is optimum, and it should never exceed 24 C.
  • pH: 7.4 to 7.6 is ideal.
  • Chlorine is harmful, and tap water needs a dechlorinator. Where chloramines are added, a dechlorinator is essential.
  • Ammonia must stay low because it is toxic. Change 10 to 20 percent of the water weekly, adjusted to test results.

Flow matters too. The RVC says filters must not create strong water flow, because that can cause severe stress. Axolotl skin is also susceptible to toxins and trauma, so handle the animal as little as possible.

Profile: the mudpuppy

The Missouri Department of Conservation describes the mudpuppy (Necturus maculosus) as permanently aquatic, with plume-like red external gills behind the head that it keeps for life. Gill size tracks the water: animals in slow, warm, low-oxygen water grow larger gills than those in faster, cooler, oxygen-rich water.

Adults are typically 8 to 13 inches long and can reach about 19 inches. They mature at 4 to 6 years and can live more than 30 years. They hide under logs and rocks by day and feed at night on crayfish, mollusks, small fish, worms and aquatic insects.

The same page links mudpuppies to a rare mussel. Larvae of the endangered salamander mussel attach to mudpuppy gills, and that mussel occurs only at a few isolated sites in the Meramec River watershed. Anglers who catch a mudpuppy are asked to release it unharmed.

Profile: the hellbender, a skin breather

The US Fish and Wildlife Service says the eastern hellbender takes in all its oxygen through its skin. Fleshy folds along the body add surface area. Hellbenders are North America’s largest salamander, growing up to two feet long, and they live in cool, permanent streams and perennial rivers in the eastern and central US.

Cool, clear water matters because it supports skin breathing. The Service lists sedimentation, water quality decline, habitat destruction, disease and direct mortality as threats. Of 626 known historical populations, it says 41 percent are believed extirpated and another 36 percent are declining.

Gills across a lifetime: two timelines

For a neotenic animal, the gills are present from hatching to old age. The RVC says axolotls reach adult size at 18 to 24 months, averaging 25 to 30 cm, and commonly live 10 to 12 years, sometimes over 20. Their gills are therefore a long-term feature of the animal, not a stage.

Mudpuppies run on a slower clock. Females lay 30 to 200 eggs in spring or summer, usually under large rocks, and incubation takes 30 to 70 days. Hatchlings are about three-quarters of an inch to one inch long and already breathe with gills.

Compare that with a frog. Britannica says tadpole gills are internal, sit under the operculum, and disappear as lungs develop. The sources we opened give no single time scale for this, so we do not state one.

Adult breathing set-ups compared

The sources above show that adult amphibians do not follow one pattern. This table sets out what each source states.

AnimalMain adult breathing routeSource
AxolotlMainly gills, some skin, rudimentary lungsRVC
MudpuppyExternal gills kept for lifeMissouri Department of Conservation
Eastern hellbenderAll oxygen through the skinUS Fish and Wildlife Service
Lungless salamandersSkin and lining of the mouth and throatNational Park Service
Adult frogs and toadsLungs and skin, no gillsBritannica

Common mistakes about amphibian gills

  • Assuming every aquatic amphibian has gills. The hellbender is fully aquatic and breathes through its skin.
  • Assuming adult frogs keep gills. Tadpole gills are lost as lungs develop.
  • Reading gill size as a health score. In mudpuppies, larger gills can simply reflect warm, low-oxygen water. We found no source that applies this rule to axolotls.
  • Adding strong filter flow to an axolotl tank. The RVC warns it can cause severe stress.
  • Treating poor water as a minor issue. Gills and skin sit directly in the water, so chlorine and ammonia reach the animal quickly.

The last point is our reasoning from the RVC and Rose and James material. It is not a measured result for any one species.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do frogs have gills?

Tadpoles do. They have internal gills covered by the operculum. Adult frogs have lost them and breathe with lungs and skin.

Do salamanders have gills?

Salamander larvae have external gills. Most adults lose them at metamorphosis. Axolotls and mudpuppies keep theirs for life.

Do newts have gills?

Newt larvae have gills, as other salamander larvae do. Newts that metamorphose resorb them, so those adults breathe with lungs and skin.

Why do axolotls keep their gills?

Axolotls stay in a juvenile form, a trait called neoteny. Crowner and colleagues (2019) link metamorphosis to thyroid hormone, and axolotls can be induced to metamorphose in the lab with it.

Can an amphibian breathe through its skin alone?

Lungless salamanders do. The National Park Service says they absorb oxygen through the skin and the lining of the mouth and throat.

Do all aquatic amphibians have gills?

No. The hellbender is fully aquatic, yet the US Fish and Wildlife Service describes it as breathing through its skin.

Bottom Line

Gills are a larval tool for most amphibians. Tadpoles and salamander larvae use them, and most species drop them as they grow.

A few salamanders never let go. Axolotls and mudpuppies stay aquatic and keep their feathery gills for life.

Sources

Similar Posts

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *